WASHINGTON— The HSUS is applauding the Bush Administration for
filing a formal objection to a maneuver by Iceland that
undermines the international treaty that governs commercial
whaling.
The State Department released a statement last week
officially objecting to Iceland’s re-admittance to the
International Whaling Commission (IWC) since Iceland rejoined
with a reservation to the treaty’s most basic tenet – a ban on
commercial whaling.
“It’s unbelievable that a country such as Iceland, with
their long history of commercial whaling and their objections
to international efforts to conserve the great whale species
should be accepted as a voting member of the IWC with a
reservation to the moratorium,” said Kitty Block, special
counsel to The HSUS’ United Nations and Treaties section. Block
will be attending this month’s IWC meeting in Berlin, Germany.
“The United States should be commended for stepping forward to
voice their disappointment by filing their official objection.
The process that allowed Iceland into the IWC was controversial
at best, and was full of confusing procedural issues. Iceland
was even allowed to vote for itself.”
The IWC was established in 1946 as a way to control the
whaling industry and conserve whale stocks. It is currently
made up of 49 countries. Over the years, the IWC has evolved
into an organization more concerned with whale conservation
then maintaining the whaling industry. Since 1986 it has banned
all commercial whaling.
Iceland was a member of the IWC until 1992 when it decided
to discontinue its membership. At a specially called meeting in
October 2002, and after two previously failed attempts, Iceland
was able to rejoin the IWC with a reservation (objection) to
the commercial whaling moratorium. The meeting in Berlin will
be the first meeting where Iceland will participate as a member
in over 11 years. Even before the start of the meeting, Iceland
has already angered many IWC members by submitting a proposal
to the 2003 meeting to immediately start to whale under the
guise of “scientific research” which is not prohibited by the
moratorium. Their scientific research plans mention that they
plan to hunt 250 whales, including northern minke, and the
endangered fin and sei whales. Iceland has also stated that it
will resume commercial whaling in 2006, so these numbers could
double.
“The United States government did the correct thing by
filing the objection, but more can be done,” said Patricia
Forkan, executive vice president of The HSUS. “The United
States can work with other IWC members to pass a resolution
admitting Iceland as a member, but rejecting its reservation to
the moratorium.”
Iceland’s readmission with a reservation also breaks with
legal precedent at the IWC. Reservations submitted in the past,
which did not include those against one of the core obligations
to the IWC, were approved by the full voting membership, not by
partial membership at a special meeting.
The HSUS has more than seven million members and
constituents. The HSUS is a mainstream voice for animals, with
active programs in companion animals and equine protection,
wildlife and habitat protection, animals in research and farm
animals and sustainable agriculture. For nearly 50 years, The
HSUS has protected all animals through legislation, litigation,
investigation, education, advocacy and field work. The
non-profit organization is based in Washington, DC and has 10
regional offices across the country. For more information,
visit The HSUS’ Web site – www.hsus.org.