WASHINGTON - The latest edition of the journal Cloning and Stem
Cells documents deaths and deformities suffered by cloned pigs
at the University of Missouri and Texas A&M.
The University of Missouri study, entitled "Phenotyping of
Transgenic Cloned Pigs," cites "a high mortality rate among
cloned piglets." Out of 10 born, five died or were destroyed by
researchers due to defects such as heart failure, lameness, and
anemia. The Texas A&M study, entitled "A Highly Efficient
Method for Porcine Cloning by Nuclear Transfer Using In Vitro -
Matured Oocytes," documents a 94% failure rate. Out of the 511
manipulated oocytes transferred, only 28 pigs came to term, one
of which was still born. Additionally, "another of the 28
piglets was born lacking an anus and tail," a fatal condition
called anal atresia. The study suggest that the deformity may
have been introduced through the cloning process: "Was the
genetic (or epigenetic) defect that led to the anal atresia
introduced during the culture of the donor cell, or was it due
to inappropriate nuclear reprogramming?"
"Deaths and deformities in cloned animals are the norm, not
the exception, and these studies make plain once again that
these creatures are suffering terribly in the process," said
Wayne Pacelle, Senior Vice President of The Humane Society of
the United States."
According to Dr. Ian Wilmut, co-creator of Dolly the sheep
"the widespread problems associated with clones has [sic] led
to questions as to whether any clone was entirely normal" ("Why
no-one should be attempting to clone a child," Roslin
Institute. Even Dolly, the product of 277 failed attempts now
suffers from arthritis and other symptoms of premature aging
possibly caused by cloning.
At a time when political debate is heating up on the topic
of whether or not to permit human cloning in the United States
and many scientists are quick to proclaim their experiments a
success, Dr. Wilmut also offers words of caution: "There is
abundant evidence that cloning can and does go wrong and no
justification for believing that this will not happen with
humans."
The first cloned human pregnancies were reported in April
and July of this year. "It should concern us all that
scientists are trying to clone humans," said Larry Bohlen,
Director of Health and Environment Programs at Friends of the
Earth. "Given the evidence of almost certain harm human cloning
should be banned."
FoE is a national environmental organization dedicated to
preserving the health and diversity of the planet and
empowering citizens to have an influential voice in decisions
affecting their environment.
The HSUS is the nation’s largest animal protection
organization with over seven million members and constituents.
With active programs in companion animals, wildlife, animals in
research and farm animals and sustainable agriculture, The HSUS
works to protect all animals through legislation, litigation,
investigation, education, advocacy and field work.