By Suzanne Millman, Ph.D.
Conditions in factory farms have
led to the routine overuse of antibiotics, which produces
antibiotic-resistant bacteria dangerous to humans and animals
alike. But humane alternatives to factory farms make antibiotic
use on the animals unnecessary—protecting humans from
untreatable diseases and animals from crowded, unsanitary
conditions.
There is little doubt that antibiotics have changed our
lives for the better, making once life-threatening
infections—from meningitis to pneumonia—treatable. But a
disturbing trend is emerging: The number of bacteria that fail
to respond to antibiotic treatment is increasing.
One cause of this increasing resistance dramatically stands
out and can be corrected: the routine overuse of antibiotics on
farm animals. The Union of Concerned Scientists estimates that
70 percent of the antibiotics used in the United States are fed
to healthy livestock and poultry to promote growth and prevent
the outbreak of disease in crowded, unsanitary factory farms.
And many of the same antibiotics prescribed to
humans—penicillin, tetracycline, and erythromycin—are used in
these factory farms.
People can become infected with resistant bacteria while
caring for farm animals who have been fed antibiotics. In turn,
farm workers can pass those bacteria to others. And waterways
and groundwater can become contaminated with resistant bacteria
leaking from manure lagoons or manure-spread fields. These
resistant bacteria can then infect people nearby who use
untreated water for drinking or recreation.
Most meat sold in U.S. supermarkets now comes from
factory-farmed animals, so another significant threat arises
from antibiotic-resistant bacteria that infect people who eat
undercooked meat or other foods contaminated with raw meat
juices. But some family farmers avoid antibiotics and instead
use more sustainable and humane methods, such as raising
animals outdoors in small groups or in "hoop barns" that
provide fresh air, space for exercise, and comfortable bedding
for rest.
Because the number of antibiotic drugs is limited and few
new antibiotics are available, the Food and Drug Administration
and the Centers for Disease Control have cautioned that without
effective action "drug choices for the treatment of common
infections will become increasingly limited and expensive and,
in some cases, nonexistent." As a result, antibiotics should be
used prudently to prolong their effectiveness.
In 1997, the World Health Organization called for a ban on
using antibiotics to promote growth in animals. In 1998, the
European Union banned adding human-use antibiotics to animal
feed, citing human health concerns. And the American Medical
Association opposes the nontherapeutic use of antibiotics in
factory-farmed animals.
The HSUS is actively involved in raising awareness about the
public health issues of factory farm antibiotic use in
livestock and poultry and encourages regulation of this
practice.
Suzanne Millman is Director of
Scientific Programs for the The Farm Animals and Sustainable
Agriculture section of The HSUS.